This isn't the sort of Challenge-...well, counter-Challenge, that tends to draw much of an audience. Certainly not compared to all of those who had shown up to see the results of Pierre's original Challenge. Typically, a debate on historical points would have perhaps those in the Deck particularly interested in its history and...a few people directly connected to either the challenger or the challenged.
Of course, this isn't a typical challenge debate, not when it will decide whether Elani McCartney remains the Jack of Clubs or if Pierre Chareut will take her place. And so the auditorium is rather more filled with people than might be expected.
The actual format is relatively simple. Both parties were given a pool of potential historical turning points in the Deck from the last century or so to research and understand what led to those turning points and what came of them. Just before the debate begins, an unbiased third party draws at random one of those topics. A coin is tossed and comes up heads, giving Pierre the choice of whether to argue for or against that turning point. He chooses
for and the participants have fifteen minutes to mentally prepare their respective arguments.
The judges' panel consists of three Cards chosen from outside of the suit of Clubs. One is a teacher of public speaking and debate at the Deck school, one is a historian for the Hearts, and the last is a historian from the Spades.
Once the research time is up, Pierre and Elani each take their places at a podium. Since he is speaking in affirmation, Pierre has the opportunity to lay out his argument first. Once his time is up, Elani sets out her opposing viewpoint before the cross examinations and rebuttals begin.
Both challengers speak well for the crowd and with conviction for the points they have chosen to debate. But in the end, the judges decide in favor of Elani due to her superior usage of the historical facts at hand.
When the winner is declared, Elani's relief is palpable in the way her shoulders settle and relax in a way they likely haven't since Pierre originally challenged her. And then the smile breaks out. She'd done it, despite the whispers that she'd crumble under the pressure, despite the simple fact that standing in opposition to Pierre was an intimidating feat in and of itself. She was still Jack and now she felt that she'd truly earned it.